How to Authenticate McCoy Pottery: 7 Ways to Determine If It's Genuine

McCoy Pottery is a highly sought after collectible that has been produced since the early 1900s. With its unique designs and high-quality craftsmanship, McCoy Pottery is a beloved addition to many collections. However, as with any valuable item, there are people who try to pass off fake pieces as genuine McCoy Pottery. If you’re a collector or simply interested in purchasing an authentic McCoy Pottery piece, it’s important to know how to authenticate it. In this article, we’ll discuss seven key ways to determine if a McCoy Pottery piece is genuine or not.

First and foremost, it’s important to familiarize yourself with the signature McCoy Pottery marks. These marks can vary depending on the time period in which the piece was produced. Look for stamps or imprints that include the word “McCoy” or the initials “MCC” followed by a number or letter. Pay attention to the size, style, and placement of the mark, as well as any additional markings such as a copyright symbol or the word “USA.” A genuine McCoy Pottery piece will have a clear and consistent mark that matches the time period in which it was produced.

Another important factor in authenticating McCoy Pottery is the glaze. McCoy Pottery is known for its distinctive glazes, which often feature vibrant colors and unique textures. Familiarize yourself with the different glazes used by McCoy Pottery over the years, such as the classic “Blossomtime” glaze or the highly sought after “Aqua Green” glaze. A genuine McCoy Pottery piece will have a glaze that matches the known glazes used by the company, and should not have any signs of flaking, cracking, or uneven application.

Additionally, take note of the overall design and style of the McCoy Pottery piece. McCoy Pottery is known for its whimsical and artistic designs, with popular motifs including animals, floral patterns, and geometric shapes. Pay attention to the level of detail and craftsmanship, as well as any unique features or characteristics that are specific to McCoy Pottery. A genuine McCoy Pottery piece will have a distinct design that matches the known styles and motifs used by the company.

It’s also important to consider the condition of the McCoy Pottery piece. Genuine McCoy Pottery pieces are often well-preserved, with minimal signs of wear or damage. While it’s possible to find genuine McCoy Pottery pieces in various conditions, be wary of pieces that show signs of excessive wear, restoration, or damage. Inspect the piece closely for any cracks, chips, or repairs that may indicate a fake or damaged item.

McCoy Pottery Authentication: How to Identify Genuine Pieces

McCoy Pottery is a highly sought-after collectible due to its unique designs and craftsmanship. However, as with any valuable item, there are counterfeit pieces in the market. It’s important to be able to authenticate McCoy Pottery to ensure you’re purchasing a genuine piece. Here are 7 ways to determine if it’s authentic:

Markings: Check for McCoy Pottery markings on the bottom of the piece. Genuine McCoy Pottery pieces are usually marked with the McCoy logo, which is a lowercase “m” in a circle or a stylized “McCoy” text.
Quality: Examine the quality of the pottery. Genuine McCoy Pottery is known for its high-quality craftsmanship and attention to detail. Look for smooth glazes, well-defined patterns, and even colors.
Style: Familiarize yourself with McCoy Pottery styles. Each McCoy Pottery era has distinct characteristics, such as the smooth matte finish of the Arts and Crafts era or the bright glazes of the Floraline line. Compare the piece you’re examining with authentic examples from the same era.
Weight: Authentic McCoy Pottery is usually heavier than its counterfeit counterparts. Counterfeit pieces may feel lighter due to the use of cheaper materials or thinner walls.
Price: If a McCoy Pottery piece is significantly cheaper than others in the market, it may be a red flag. Be wary of deals that seem too good to be true, as they often are.
Seller: Buy from reputable sellers and dealers who have a proven track record of selling genuine McCoy Pottery. Avoid sellers with no return policies or questionable feedback.
Expert Opinion: If you’re unsure about the authenticity of a McCoy Pottery piece, seek the opinion of an expert. They have the knowledge and experience to identify genuine McCoy Pottery and can help you make an informed decision.

By following these guidelines, you can increase your chances of purchasing genuine McCoy Pottery and avoid being scammed by counterfeit pieces. Remember to always do your research and buy from trusted sources to ensure the authenticity of your McCoy Pottery collection.

Examining the Markings

One of the first things to look for when authenticating McCoy pottery is the presence of markings on the piece. These markings can provide valuable information about the manufacturer, date of production, and other identifying details. Here are some key points to consider:

Manufacturer’s Initials: McCoy pottery is typically marked with the letters “McCoy” or “McCoy USA.” Look for these initials, either stamped or incised, to confirm the piece’s authenticity.
Consistency: Pay attention to the style, font, and size of the markings. Genuine McCoy pottery will have consistent markings throughout the collection. Look for any variations or inconsistencies that may indicate a reproduction or imitation.
Positioning: The location of the markings can also be an important clue. Authentic McCoy pottery usually has the markings placed in a consistent and specific area, such as the bottom or the base of the piece.
Quality of Markings: Take a close look at the markings to assess their quality. Authentic McCoy pottery will have clear, well-defined markings, without any smudging, fading, or other imperfections.
Additional Information: In addition to the manufacturer’s initials, McCoy pottery markings may include other information such as a model number, pattern name, or production year. Look for these details to further verify the piece’s authenticity.

It’s important to note that some McCoy pottery pieces may not have any markings at all. This is more common with older pieces or those that were produced during certain time periods. In such cases, it may be necessary to rely on other authentication methods, such as the style, glaze, or construction of the pottery.

By carefully examining the markings on McCoy pottery, you can gain valuable insights into its authenticity and help distinguish it from reproductions or imitations. Remember to consult reference books, online resources, and expert opinions to verify the information and confirm the piece’s genuineness.

Inspecting the Glaze

One important factor to consider when authenticating McCoy pottery is the glaze. The glaze is the glossy or matte finish applied to the pottery to give it a smooth and attractive appearance. Here are a few steps to help you inspect the glaze and determine if it’s genuine:

Check for consistency: A genuine McCoy pottery piece will have a consistent glaze throughout the entire surface. Look for any variations in color or texture, as this could indicate a reproduction.
Examine the finish: McCoy pottery is known for its high-quality glaze finish that is smooth, shiny, and even. If you notice any rough spots, bubbles, or inconsistencies in the glaze, it may be a sign of a fake.
Look for crazing: Crazing refers to the fine cracks or lines that may appear on the glaze over time. McCoy pottery is often prone to crazing, and a genuine piece will likely show signs of aging in the form of slight crazing. However, be cautious of excessive crazing or crazing that appears artificial.
Check the color: McCoy pottery often features unique and vibrant glaze colors. Research the specific color variations for the McCoy patterns you are examining and compare them to the piece in question. Any variation in color that doesn’t match known McCoy glazes could indicate a reproduction.
Observe the texture: The glaze on McCoy pottery should have a smooth and consistent texture. Run your fingers gently over the surface to feel for any rough patches, unevenness, or irregularities.

By carefully inspecting the glaze of a McCoy pottery piece, you can gain valuable clues about its authenticity. Remember to compare your findings with known McCoy glaze characteristics and consult experts or reference materials for further guidance.

Analyzing the Shape and Design

When trying to authenticate McCoy pottery, one of the key aspects to consider is the shape and design of the piece. McCoy pottery is known for its distinct shapes and patterns, which can help determine its authenticity.

Familiarize yourself with McCoy styles: Research and become familiar with the various McCoy pottery styles that were produced. This will help you identify the common shapes and designs associated with McCoy pottery.
Inspect the shape: Examine the shape of the pottery piece closely. McCoy pottery typically features clean lines and balanced proportions. Look for symmetrical shapes and smooth curves, as these are characteristic of genuine McCoy pieces.
Look for unique designs: McCoy pottery often includes unique and eye-catching designs. Look for patterns such as floral motifs, bumpy textures, or geometric shapes. These design elements can indicate authenticity.
Check for consistency: McCoy pottery was produced in large quantities, so consistency in the shape and design is important. Compare the piece you are examining to known McCoy pieces to see if it matches in terms of shape, size, and design elements.
Pay attention to details: Examine any hand-painted or molded details on the pottery piece. Genuine McCoy pieces often have precise and well-executed details, such as well-defined mold lines or clean brushwork. Poorly executed or sloppy details may indicate a reproduction or fake.
Check for mold marks: Genuine McCoy pottery may have mold marks on the bottom or sides of the piece. These marks are often indicators of authenticity and can help authenticate the piece.
Consult reference materials: If you are unsure about the shape and design of a McCoy pottery piece, consult reference materials, such as collector’s guides or online resources. These can provide valuable information on the various shapes and designs produced by McCoy Pottery.

By carefully analyzing the shape and design of a McCoy pottery piece, you can increase your chances of authenticating it. Remember to compare the piece to known McCoy styles and consult reference materials for additional guidance.

Researching the History

When trying to authenticate a piece of McCoy pottery, it’s important to start by researching its history. This involves gathering information about the company, its production methods, and the various marks and signatures used throughout its existence.

Here are some key steps to take when researching the history of McCoy pottery:

Find reputable sources: Start by looking for reputable sources that provide accurate information about McCoy pottery. This could include books, websites, and other educational resources.
Learn about the company: Familiarize yourself with the history of the McCoy pottery company. Understand when it was founded, who the key players were, and how it evolved over time.
Study production methods: McCoy pottery went through different production methods during its history. Learn about the different techniques used for molding, glazing, and firing the pottery.
Identify common markings: McCoy pottery often carries marks and signatures that can help in its identification. Study the different marks commonly found on McCoy pieces and understand their significance.
Compare with known examples: Look for authenticated McCoy pottery pieces that are similar to the one you are trying to authenticate. Compare the marks, signatures, and characteristics to see if they match.
Consult experts: If you’re having difficulty authenticating a piece of McCoy pottery, consider seeking advice from experts or collectors who have experience with McCoy pottery. They may be able to provide additional insights or help you verify its authenticity.
Keep learning: Authenticating pottery, including McCoy pottery, can be a continuous learning process. Stay updated with new information, research, and resources to enhance your knowledge and authentication skills.

By conducting thorough research on the history of McCoy pottery, you can better equip yourself with the knowledge and understanding needed to authenticate its pieces accurately.

Comparing with Reference Books

One of the most reliable ways to determine the authenticity of McCoy Pottery is by comparing it with reference books. These books contain detailed information about the history, styles, and markings of McCoy Pottery pieces.

Here are the steps to follow when using reference books to authenticate McCoy Pottery:

Choose a reputable reference book: Look for books written by experts or collectors who have extensive knowledge of McCoy Pottery. Check reviews and ratings to ensure you are using a reliable source.
Identify the specific piece: Determine the shape, size, and design of the McCoy Pottery piece. Look for any distinctive characteristics or features that can help you identify the piece accurately.
Check the markings: Look for any markings or signatures on the bottom of the pottery piece. Compare these markings with the ones listed in the reference book. Pay attention to the style, font, and placement of the markings.
Compare the glaze: Examine the glaze on the McCoy Pottery piece. Look for any unique colors, textures, or patterns. Compare the glaze with the examples provided in the reference book to see if they match.
Consider the time period: McCoy Pottery was produced over several decades, and different time periods had different styles and markings. Consult the reference book to determine the time period of the piece you are examining and compare it with the characteristics of that period.
Look for documentation: Some McCoy Pottery pieces may come with original packaging, labels, or paperwork. Check the reference book to see if any documentation exists for the specific piece you are examining. This can provide additional evidence of authenticity.
Use caution and expertise: While reference books are valuable resources, they are not foolproof. Always use your judgment, and if you have any doubts, consider seeking the assistance of an expert or experienced collector to authenticate the McCoy Pottery piece.

By comparing McCoy Pottery with reference books, you can gain a deeper understanding of its history and characteristics. This knowledge will help you determine if a piece is genuine or not.

Seeking Expert Opinions

When it comes to authenticating McCoy pottery, seeking expert opinions can provide valuable insights. There are several ways you can go about finding experts, including:

McCoy Pottery Collectors Club: Joining a collectors club dedicated to McCoy pottery can connect you with experienced collectors who have a deep knowledge of the brand. They can offer guidance on authenticating pieces and may be able to recommend trusted experts.
Auction Houses: Auction houses that specialize in pottery and ceramics often have experts on staff who can assess the authenticity of McCoy pottery. They may offer appraisal services or be able to refer you to experts in the field.
Antique Dealers: Local antique dealers who specialize in pottery and ceramics may have knowledge of McCoy pottery authentication. They can examine pieces in person and provide their expert opinion based on their experience and training.
Online Forums and Communities: Participating in online forums and communities dedicated to pottery collecting can be a great way to connect with fellow enthusiasts and seek their opinions on the authenticity of McCoy pottery. These forums often have knowledgeable members who can share their expertise.
McCoy Pottery Experts: There are individuals who have gained a reputation for their expertise in McCoy pottery. They may have published books or articles on the subject, or they might offer consulting services. Researching and contacting these experts can provide you with valuable insights.

It’s important to keep in mind that while seeking expert opinions can be helpful, it’s still essential to educate yourself about the key features and characteristics of authentic McCoy pottery. This knowledge will empower you to make more informed decisions and reduce the risk of relying solely on others’ opinions.

Checking for Authentic Packaging

One way to determine if McCoy pottery is genuine is by examining its packaging. Here are some tips to help you check for authentic packaging:

Look for the McCoy logo: Authentic McCoy pottery usually comes in packaging that features the McCoy logo. The logo can vary depending on the time period, so do some research to familiarize yourself with different versions of the logo.
Check for original labels: McCoy pottery may have original labels attached to the packaging. These labels often include information about the company, the specific item, and any special markings or features to look for.
Inspect the quality: Authentic packaging is usually well-made and shows attention to detail. Look for signs of high-quality printing, sturdy materials, and accurate labeling.
Compare with reference images: Use reference images or catalogs from reputable sources to compare the packaging of your McCoy pottery with known authentic examples. Look for matching logos, colors, fonts, and other design details.

Keep in mind that packaging can be reproduced or replaced, so while authentic packaging is a good indicator of genuine McCoy pottery, it is not foolproof. It’s best to use packaging inspection in combination with other authentication methods to make a more accurate determination.

FAQ:

How can I determine if my McCoy pottery is genuine?

There are several ways to authenticate McCoy pottery. One way is to look for the McCoy mark on the bottom of the piece. Genuine McCoy pieces will have a distinct mark that includes the McCoy name or logo, along with other identifying information. Another way is to research the specific piece or pattern you have. McCoy pottery has a long history, and there are many resources available that can help you determine if your piece is genuine. Additionally, you can seek the advice of experts or collectors who may be able to provide further guidance.

What should I look for in the McCoy mark?

The McCoy mark can vary depending on the time period in which the piece was made. However, a genuine McCoy mark will typically include the McCoy name or logo, along with other identifying information such as the country of origin or a model number. The mark should be clear and well-defined, and should not appear faded or blurred. It’s important to compare the mark on your piece to verified examples of McCoy marks to ensure its authenticity.

Are there any specific patterns or designs that are commonly found on McCoy pottery?

Yes, there are several patterns and designs that are commonly found on McCoy pottery. Some popular patterns include the “Flowerpot” pattern, which features a raised flower design, and the “Blossom Time” pattern, which features a floral motif. Other common designs include basketweave patterns, embossed fruit patterns, and matte glazes. However, it’s important to note that not all McCoy pottery will have a specific pattern or design, as they produced a wide range of pieces in different styles over the years.

Can I use the weight of the pottery to determine its authenticity?

While the weight of a piece of pottery can sometimes provide some clues about its authenticity, it is not a foolproof method for determining if it is genuine McCoy pottery. The weight of McCoy pottery can vary depending on factors such as the size of the piece and the specific clay used. Additionally, there are many factors that can contribute to the weight of a piece, including the thickness of the walls and the presence of any additional decorative elements. Therefore, it’s best to rely on other methods, such as examining the mark or researching the piece, to determine its authenticity.

Tips for identifying authentic McCoy pottery